At a dinner party in 1791, Thomas Jefferson pointed to the portraits on his wall, Locke, Bacon, and Newton, and called them the greatest men in history. Alexander Hamilton replied that the greatest man who ever lived was Julius Caesar. From that exchange, Jeffrey Rosen argues, came America's two political parties and the argument that has defined every constitutional crisis since: Jefferson saw every increase in power as a threat to liberty; Hamilton believed power, properly structured, is what secures it. With a Supreme Court that now decides cases by competing accounts of history, that argument is no longer background reading. It is doctrine.
In this TalksOnLaw interview, Joel Cohen speaks with Jeffrey Rosen, CEO Emeritus of the National Constitution Center, which he led from 2013 to 2026, Professor of Law at The George Washington University, and author of The Pursuit of Liberty: How Hamilton vs. Jefferson Ignited the Lasting Battle Over Power in America, about the founders' three great debates (national power versus states' rights, democracy versus rule by elites, and liberal versus strict construction) and how they are being refought in the Supreme Court's 2026 decisions on birthright citizenship, the independent agencies, and presidential power.
Necessary and Proper
Rosen traces the fight over the Bank of the United States, where Jefferson read "necessary" to mean indispensable, Hamilton stayed up all night writing 14,000 words to read it as "useful," and John Marshall, with Hamilton's memo beside him, wrote the Hamiltonian view into McCulloch. He then follows the same question through the Louisiana Purchase, which Jefferson thought unconstitutional and made anyway, the Missouri Compromise and Dred Scott, the post-Civil War legal tender cases in which Congress shrank and re-expanded the Court to get the answer it wanted, and the Affordable Care Act. His conclusion: the real divide in American constitutional law is not originalism versus living constitutionalism but liberal versus strict construction, a divide that runs through today's originalists, with Scalia, Roberts, and Barrett on Hamilton's side and Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch on Jefferson's. He explains why none of Jefferson, Hamilton, or Madison would qualify as an originalist today, and why Madison's willingness to change his mind ("Nothing, my dear, only a change of mind," his last words) is the better model.
Sovereignty, Secession, and Religion
Previewing his next book on the Constitutional Convention's four most frequent speakers, Rosen contrasts James Wilson's "We the People of the United States," Roger Sherman's compact of sovereign states, and Madison's dual sovereignty, and shows how those positions resurfaced in Jefferson's Kentucky Resolutions, Calhoun's defense of nullification, and Lincoln at Gettysburg. He connects the founders' religious disagreements, from Sherman's Puritan establishments to Madison's Memorial and Remonstrance, to Justice Gorsuch's 2026 rebuke of the claim that America is a "Christian nation."
Presidential Power from Roosevelt to Trump
Turning to Article II, Rosen sets Theodore Roosevelt's claim that the president may do anything the Constitution does not forbid against Taft's view that he may do only what it allows, and explains how the 1912 election fixed three competing visions of the administrative state that still sort American conservatives. He walks through the rise of governing by executive order, Myers v. United States and Brandeis's dissent ("not efficiency, but liberty"), the unitary executive theory from Hamilton's Pacificus letters to Reagan, and the Supreme Court's June 2026 decision in Trump v. Slaughter overruling Humphrey's Executor, in which the Chief Justice cited Rosen's biography of Taft, together with the companion ruling that kept the Federal Reserve's Lisa Cook in office. He closes with the question his book leaves open, whether the current president is a Caesar or an Andrew Jackson, with the 1800 election, Burr's conspiracy, and the duel at Weehawken, and with the bust of Hamilton that Jefferson kept facing his own at Monticello: "opposed in life as in death," a rival to be engaged rather than destroyed.







