Key Takeaways
- The Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act of 2005 bars most lawsuits seeking to hold gun makers and sellers liable for harm caused by someone else's criminal misuse of a firearm.
- Suits can still proceed under the law's exceptions, including negligent entrustment, defective products, and the “predicate exception” for knowing violations of laws governing firearm sales or marketing.
- In 2025 the Supreme Court unanimously threw out Mexico's suit against U.S. gunmakers, holding that it did not plausibly allege the companies aided and abetted illegal gun sales.
When a gun is used in a crime, can the victims sue the company that made or sold it?
In this TalksOnLaw Brief, Joel Cohen talks with Jody Madeira, Professor of Law at the Indiana University Maurer School of Law, about the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act (PLCAA), the federal law that gives the firearms industry broad protection from civil suits, and the exceptions that still allow some cases to go forward.
Why Congress Passed the PLCAA
Professor Madeira explains that in the 1990s, cities such as Philadelphia, Chicago, and Gary, Indiana, sued the industry, alleging that firearms were a public nuisance tied to drug crime and soaring law enforcement costs. The industry lobbied Congress, arguing it was being blamed for the acts of criminal third parties. Congress responded in 2005 with the PLCAA, codified at 15 U.S.C. §§ 7901–7903, which went from start to President George W. Bush's signature in about eight months. Some defend the immunity as protecting an industry essential to exercising a constitutional right; critics argue Congress had never before given an industry such extensive protection.
The Exceptions
The law bars damages suits against manufacturers, dealers, and other industry members for harm resulting from a third party's criminal or unlawful misuse of a firearm. Professor Madeira walks through the exceptions: negligent entrustment, breach of contract or warranty, defective design or manufacture when the gun is used as intended, enforcement actions by the Attorney General under federal gun laws, and the “predicate exception” for knowing violations of a state or federal statute applicable to the sale or marketing of firearms that proximately cause the harm. Most litigation, she says, runs through the predicate exception. In the Badger Guns case in Milwaukee, a jury found a dealer liable to two police officers shot with a gun obtained through a straw purchase, and she describes the warning signs dealers are trained to spot.
State Shields and the Sandy Hook Settlement
Some states add their own immunity. Professor Madeira describes Indiana's statute as among the strictest in the country, and notes that Arkansas and Indiana can require unsuccessful plaintiffs to pay the industry's legal fees; a Colorado couple who sued an online ammunition seller after the Aurora theater shooting faced a similar fee award. On marketing, she discusses the 2022 Sandy Hook settlement, in which $73 million was paid on behalf of Remington to families who alleged that ads for the Bushmaster XM15, including “Consider your man card reissued,” violated Connecticut's unfair trade practices law. She cautions that Remington was in bankruptcy and the case settled, so no jury tested the theory.
What to Know Now
The PLCAA remains the central federal shield, and the Supreme Court has now interpreted it for the first time. In Smith & Wesson Brands, Inc. v. Estados Unidos Mexicanos (2025), the Court unanimously held, in an opinion by Justice Kagan, that Mexico's suit against U.S. gunmakers was barred because it did not plausibly allege that the companies aided and abetted dealers' unlawful sales to traffickers. At the same time, states have written laws designed to fit the predicate exception. In 2025 the Second Circuit rejected a facial challenge to New York's public nuisance statute aimed at gun industry members, and in 2026 the Supreme Court declined to review that decision. Supporters of the PLCAA read the Mexico ruling as confirming that lawful commerce should not be punished for criminals' acts; victims' advocates note that suits based on specific, knowing misconduct in sales or marketing, the theory behind Sandy Hook, remain available.


