Key Takeaways
- Investment treaties let investors from one country bring arbitration claims directly against another treaty country that mistreats their investments, without relying on that country's courts.
- Typical protections include compensation for expropriation, fair and equitable treatment, protection from discrimination, and the free transfer of funds home.
- Companies can often gain treaty coverage by investing through a country with a suitable treaty, but that planning needs to happen before a dispute is foreseeable.
When a foreign government targets a technology company with regulation that seems designed to protect local competitors, what can the company do besides go to that country's own courts?
In this TalksOnLaw Brief, Joel Cohen talks with Elliot Friedman, a partner at Freshfields and head of its international arbitration practice in the Americas, and Thomas Walsh, a partner in the firm's international arbitration group in New York, about how investment treaties can give tech companies a way to fight back.
What an Investment Treaty Does
Friedman explains that these protections were historically used after a government seized an investment outright, but that tech companies now face interference as countries use foreign investment rules, antitrust policy, and other regulation as political leverage. Walsh describes investment treaties as a relatively new solution to an old problem: states mistreating foreign investors. In the past, an investor could sue in the courts of the very state that mistreated it, or ask its own government to take up the claim. Investment treaties, whether bilateral or multilateral, instead protect investments that citizens of one treaty country make in another. The guests note there are more than 3,000 such treaties worldwide, and the United States is party to more than 40.
The Protections
Most treaties, Friedman explains, contain similar protections: a guarantee against expropriation, a right to fair and equitable treatment that tribunals have largely read to protect an investor's legitimate expectations, protection against discrimination favoring local or third-country competitors, and the right to transfer revenues home. Most important, treaties let private investors bring arbitration claims directly against a foreign state, which by signing waives significant parts of its sovereign immunity. Cases are often brought at the World Bank's ICSID or the Permanent Court of Arbitration. As an example, the guests point to Uber's claim against Colombia after regulators took steps that largely affected only Uber, apparently to protect local taxi companies. They explain that the claim gave Uber leverage to negotiate, and they understand the matter was resolved favorably on confidential terms.
Qualifying and Structuring
Qualifying does not take much, Friedman says. A U.S. company investing in a country that has a treaty with the United States is covered automatically. If no treaty exists, the investment can often be routed through a subsidiary in a country that has one, such as the Netherlands, so the guests advise checking the treaty landscape at the outset of any major investment. They also highlight two trends: any state can now be a respondent, because governments struggle to regulate new technologies; and cloud-based businesses, despite seeming to float in the ether, are tied closely enough to the countries they serve that the guests believe they qualify for protection.
What to Know Now
Investment treaties remain a powerful tool, and technology disputes continue to emerge, including Huawei's ICSID claim against Sweden over its exclusion from the country's 5G rollout. The landscape has also shifted in places. EU member states terminated their bilateral investment treaties with one another, and the EU's withdrawal from the Energy Charter Treaty took effect in 2025, reflecting the view that investor-state arbitration between EU parties conflicts with EU law. Timing matters for structuring as well: in Philip Morris Asia v. Australia, a tribunal treated a restructuring made after a dispute was foreseeable as an abuse of rights and declined jurisdiction. Supporters see treaties as protection against politically driven regulation, while critics argue they constrain legitimate public policy. For companies investing abroad, the guests' advice to plan treaty coverage early remains the key takeaway.


