Key Takeaways
- Under the Fourth Amendment, police may use deadly force when they reasonably believe a person poses a threat of death or serious bodily harm to the officer or others.
- Tennessee v. Garner bars deadly force against a fleeing suspect who poses no significant danger, but it may be allowed where there is probable cause the suspect committed a violent crime.
- Many states set stricter limits than the Constitution, and in 2025 the Supreme Court confirmed that courts must consider all the circumstances, not just the final moment.
Videos of police killings, some with little or no apparent justification, have led many people to ask a basic question: what does the law actually allow? When can police officers use deadly force?
In this TalksOnLaw Brief, Rachel Harmon, the Harrison Robertson Professor of Law and Director of the Center for Criminal Justice at the University of Virginia School of Law and a former federal prosecutor, explains the constitutional rule in conversation with TalksOnLaw host Joel Cohen, and why the Constitution is only one of the checks on police force.
Two Circumstances for Deadly Force
Professor Harmon explains that police can generally use deadly force in two circumstances. The most common is when an officer faces a threat of force that would cause death or serious bodily harm, whether to the officer or to another person. The second is when someone is fleeing a dangerous crime, having been engaged in a crime of violence, and deadly force is the only way to stop them. She adds that officers do not always use force in these circumstances, and that not every state permits the full range of force the Supreme Court's case law allows.
Tennessee v. Garner and the Fleeing Suspect
Under Tennessee v. Garner, Professor Harmon says, an officer cannot shoot a non-dangerous fleeing felon but can shoot a dangerous one. In the Court's view, a person is dangerous when actively threatening or using serious force against an officer or someone else. But the Court also suggested a second form of dangerousness: being suspected of a violent crime. Asked about a suspect accused of a terrible crime who may turn out to be the wrong person, she agrees that deadly force against that fleeing suspect would appear to be constitutionally justified under Garner. Police departments, officers, and communities cringe at that result, she notes, and departments face the court of public opinion more often than federal constitutional cases. As a result, when officers use deadly force, the justification offered is usually that they or someone else faced a threat.
Systems, Not Just Bad Actors
Despite her years as a prosecutor, including on policing cases, Professor Harmon does not think criminal prosecution is the best way to handle most problems in policing, though it can show respect for victims as equal citizens. Focusing on the individual officer is often a mistake, she argues. Policing is about systems: the behavior we authorize, how departments are structured, and the tasks they are given. The problems, in her view, usually result from institutions rather than bad people.
What to Know Now
Tennessee v. Garner and Graham v. Connor remain the foundation of the constitutional rule. In Barnes v. Felix (2025), a unanimous Supreme Court rejected the "moment-of-threat" approach some lower courts had used, which looked only at the instant an officer perceived danger, and held that courts must consider the totality of the circumstances, including events leading up to the use of force. The Court left open how an officer's own creation of a dangerous situation should factor in. Many states now impose limits stricter than the Constitution; California, for example, has since 2020 permitted deadly force only when an officer reasonably believes it is necessary. Federal policy has shifted as well: a 2022 executive order on policing standards was rescinded in January 2025, and an April 2025 order directed the Justice Department to review federal consent decrees with police departments. Supporters see these moves as backing officers; critics worry they weaken the systemic oversight Professor Harmon emphasizes.


