Series: Your Rights with Police →

Is There a Right to Record the Police?

Most federal appeals courts now protect filming police in public, but buffer laws and immunity still matter.

Prof. Jocelyn SimonsonBrooklyn Law School
Duration: 3:4915,381 views

Key Takeaways

  • The Supreme Court has never decided whether the First Amendment protects recording police, but nine federal appeals courts have now recognized that right in public.
  • The right covers recording itself, not interfering with officers, so physically getting involved or defying lawful orders can still lead to arrest.
  • Even where the right exists, officers may receive qualified immunity if it was not clearly established when they acted, and some states now enforce buffer-distance laws around police.

You see a police encounter unfolding and pull out your phone to film it. Can an officer order you to stop, tell you to leave, or take your phone?

In this TalksOnLaw Brief, Jocelyn Simonson, now the Herman Badillo '54 Professor of Law at Brooklyn Law School, where she teaches criminal law, criminal procedure, and evidence, explains whether there is a First Amendment right to record police officers in public. Her answer is "maybe": the general sense is yes, she says, but the law is more complicated than that.

What the Courts Had Said

Professor Simonson explains that the Supreme Court has never said there is a First Amendment right to record the police. What it has protected is the right to criticize officers, even to curse at them and be loud and disrespectful, up to the point of interfering with public safety. Lower courts, she notes, had mostly said either that a right to record exists or that it probably does but is not yet clearly established. At the time of the brief, only four federal courts of appeals had squarely recognized the right, and a federal court in Philadelphia had held that no such right existed.

Wiretapping Laws and the Phone in Your Hand

People have been arrested for recording police under state laws that prohibit secretly recording others. That, Professor Simonson explains, is where the First Amendment matters: if the right exists, those wiretapping laws cannot be applied to public officials doing their jobs in public, and she notes that most such laws already exempt them. In a circuit that clearly recognizes the right, such as the First Circuit, which covers Boston, it is unconstitutional for an officer to order you to stop recording, make you leave, confiscate your phone to look at it, or delete your video, unless you are doing something more, such as putting your body between an officer and the person being arrested.

The Law on the Books and on the Street

Even where the law is clear, Professor Simonson observes, events do not always follow it. A phone pointed at an officer in a heated moment can raise tensions, and across the country officers have confiscated phones and arrested people for disorderly conduct or for failing to obey orders to back up. She predicted that the number of cases would keep growing, making it important to watch how courts interpret the right over time.

What to Know Now

The courts have moved in the direction Professor Simonson anticipated. The Third Circuit reversed the Philadelphia ruling in Fields v. City of Philadelphia (2017), and the Fifth, Tenth, and Fourth Circuits followed. In August 2026, the Second Circuit joined them in Massimino v. Benoit, bringing to nine the circuits that recognize a First Amendment right to record law enforcement activity in public. The Sixth, Eighth, and D.C. Circuits have not squarely done so, and the Supreme Court has not taken up the question. Qualified immunity remains a significant hurdle: in Massimino, the court held that the right was not clearly established at the time of the 2018 arrest, so the officers were not liable. A newer front involves buffer laws that let officers order bystanders to stay a set distance away. The Seventh Circuit upheld Indiana's 25-foot law against a First Amendment challenge but separately affirmed an injunction against it as unconstitutionally vague, and a federal judge declined to block a similar Tennessee law in 2026. Supporters say such laws protect officer safety; critics say they chill lawful recording.

Additional Resources

Cases

  • Glik v. Cunniffe (1st Cir. 2011): The First Circuit decision recognizing a clear right to record police in public, the Boston example Professor Simonson describes.
  • Fields v. City of Philadelphia (3d Cir. 2017): Reversed the Philadelphia district court ruling she mentions and recognized the right to record.
  • Irizarry v. Yehia (10th Cir. 2022): Held that the right to film police performing their duties in public was clearly established in the Tenth Circuit.
  • Massimino v. Benoit (2d Cir. 2026): Joined eight sister circuits in recognizing the right, while granting officers qualified immunity.
  • City of Houston v. Hill (1987): Protected the right to verbally challenge and criticize police officers, the speech protection she contrasts with recording.
  • Nicodemus v. City of South Bend (7th Cir. 2025): Upheld Indiana's 25-foot police buffer law as a reasonable time, place, and manner restriction.

Statutes and Rules

  • 42 U.S.C. § 1983: The federal civil rights statute under which most right-to-record lawsuits are brought, and where qualified immunity applies.