Series: First Amendment →

Do You Have a Heckler's Veto Right?

Why shouting down a speaker you oppose undermines free speech, and how the heckler's veto doctrine began.

Prof. Nadine StrossenFormer President, ACLU; Professor Emerita, NY Law School
Duration: 2:572,698 views

Key Takeaways

  • A heckler's veto occurs when opponents shout down or disrupt a speaker, or when officials silence the speaker because of a hostile audience's reaction.
  • The Supreme Court developed protection against the heckler's veto largely in civil rights era cases, ruling that officials must protect peaceful speakers rather than stop them.
  • Peaceful counter protest is protected speech, but silencing a speaker undercuts the rights of both the speaker and audience members who want to listen.

In recent years, speakers on college campuses have been shouted down, shut down, or violently disrupted by people who oppose their views. Is there a right to stop a speaker whose ideas you find hateful?

In this TalksOnLaw Brief, Nadine Strossen, John Marshall Harlan II Professor of Law Emerita at New York Law School and former president of the American Civil Liberties Union, explains the heckler's veto, where the concept came from, and why it applies no matter whose speech is under attack.

No Right to Silence a Speaker

Professor Strossen's answer is direct: there is no right to a heckler's veto. In her view, shutting down a speaker violates the speaker's free speech rights. It also violates the rights of audience members who want to hear the message, however unpopular. The constitutional doctrine itself is aimed at government: officials may not suppress a speaker because an audience reacts with hostility, and a public university may enforce neutral rules against disruptions that prevent an event from going forward.

Born in the Civil Rights Movement

Professor Strossen notes that the Supreme Court developed the concept of an unlawful heckler's veto during the civil rights movement of the 1960s. Martin Luther King Jr. and other activists carried messages that were deeply unpopular in many parts of the country. Officials tried to stop them from speaking and demonstrating, arguing that their opponents would respond with violence. And there was violence: rocks and bottles were thrown, and people were injured. The Supreme Court, she explains, held that this amounted to an illegal heckler's veto, and that government must use its available resources to prevent violence rather than silence the speakers.

A Neutral Principle

Today, she observes, the heckler's veto is often wielded in an attempt to suppress racist or other hateful speech. But the principle is neutral. The same rule that protected civil rights marchers protects speakers whose views many find offensive, and the protection only works if it applies to everyone.

What to Know Now

The doctrine Professor Strossen describes remains firmly established. In cases such as Edwards v. South Carolina (1963), Cox v. Louisiana (1965), and Gregory v. City of Chicago (1969), the Court overturned convictions of peaceful demonstrators whose audiences grew hostile, and in Forsyth County v. Nationalist Movement (1992) it barred governments from charging speakers more for security because of expected opposition. Courts continue to apply the principle; in 2026, for example, the Sixth Circuit held that a school board could not cut off a public commenter because the crowd booed her.

The campus debate has intensified with disruptions at law schools and universities and with protests over the war in Gaza. Many schools and several states have adopted policies that protect peaceful protest while prohibiting conduct that substantially disrupts an event. Advocates on different sides argue over where vigorous protest ends and silencing begins, and some argue that certain hateful speech warrants a stronger response. Professor Strossen's position is that the better answer to speech we oppose is more speech, and that peaceful counter protest, picketing, and walking out remain fully available.

Additional Resources

Cases

Books

  • HATE: Why We Should Resist It with Free Speech, Not Censorship (2018): Professor Strossen's book-length case for counter speech over censorship.
  • The War on Words: 10 Arguments Against Free Speech, and Why They Fail (2025): Co-written with Greg Lukianoff, addressing common arguments for limiting speech.