Series: Injury and Victims' Rights →

Brain Injury Liability at Birth (Illinois)

When a newborn's brain injury is malpractice in Illinois: proving negligence, causation, and lifelong damages.

Patrick A. Salvi IISalvi, Schostok & Pritchard
Duration: 16:51421 views

Key Takeaways

  • A birth brain injury supports a malpractice claim only if providers fell below the standard of care and that failure caused the injury.
  • Evidence of an acute injury around the time of delivery, such as a newborn being treated with brain cooling, is often central to proving causation.
  • Illinois has no caps on medical malpractice damages, so a jury can award the full cost of lifelong care and non-economic losses.

When a baby suffers a brain injury during labor and delivery, when does the tragedy become a case of medical malpractice? And how do families prove what went wrong?

In this TalksOnLaw Brief, Joel Cohen talks with Patrick A. Salvi II, Managing Equity Partner at the Chicago personal injury firm Salvi, Schostok & Pritchard P.C., about how birth brain injury cases are investigated, what plaintiffs must prove, and how Illinois law shapes the damages families can recover.

Negligence and Causation

Salvi explains that a lawyer reviewing a birth injury case asks two questions. First, was there negligence? Often the issue is a delay in delivery. Fetal monitor strips track the baby's heart rate, and abnormal patterns can signal a drop in oxygen and a pending brain injury. When those signs appear, nurses and doctors need to act. If they responded appropriately and an injury still occurred, there is no case.

Second, did the negligence cause the injury? Salvi describes the key question as whether there was an acute hypoxic-ischemic event, meaning a brain injury from low oxygen and reduced blood flow that occurred in and around the time of birth. Proving it typically takes many experts: an obstetrician or maternal-fetal medicine specialist and an obstetrical nurse on the standard of care, and a pediatric neurologist, pediatric neuroradiologist, and placental pathologist on causation.

What Makes a Strong Case

Strong cases usually show immediate findings after delivery. Salvi points to therapeutic brain cooling, which neonatologists use when they suspect a recent brain injury, as one sign that the injury happened during labor and delivery. By contrast, when nothing dramatic occurred during delivery and concerns arose only later as a child missed milestones, he says the odds are against a case. He describes turning away families as the hardest part of his job, and stresses that lawyers serve as gatekeepers who should bring only meritorious cases, against providers who are usually doing their best.

Illinois Law and Damages

Salvi calls Illinois a favorable venue for injured patients because it has no caps on medical malpractice damages, unlike neighboring Indiana, which caps total recovery, and states that cap non-economic damages. Damages cover economic losses such as decades of 24-hour nursing care, medications, and equipment, and non-economic losses such as the loss of a normal life. He describes life expectancy as a major battleground: plaintiffs' experts may project a near-normal lifespan with good care, while defense experts may argue for a much shorter one.

What to Know Now

The framework Salvi describes remains in place. Illinois has had no statutory damage caps in malpractice cases since the Illinois Supreme Court struck down the 2005 caps in Lebron v. Gottlieb Memorial Hospital (2010). Indiana's cap on total recovery is now $1.8 million for malpractice occurring after June 30, 2019. Since 2021, Illinois has also added prejudgment interest of 6 percent a year in personal injury cases, running from the date of filing, and appellate courts upheld that statute in 2023, including in Cotton v. Coccaro, a malpractice case; defense groups continue to criticize it. Illinois also gives minors injured by malpractice up to eight years from the injury to sue, but not past their 22nd birthday. Families with concerns should have the medical records reviewed early.

Additional Resources

Statutes and Cases

  • 735 ILCS 5/13-212 (current): Illinois malpractice limitations rule, including the eight-year, age-22 limit for injured minors.
  • 735 ILCS 5/2-1303(c) (2021): Adds 6 percent annual prejudgment interest in Illinois personal injury and wrongful death cases.
  • Lebron v. Gottlieb Memorial Hospital (Ill. 2010): Struck down Illinois caps on non-economic damages in medical malpractice cases.
  • Cotton v. Coccaro (Ill. App. 2023): Upheld the constitutionality of the prejudgment interest statute in a malpractice case.