Series: Injury and Victims' Rights →

Modified Comparative Fault in New Jersey

Partly at fault in a New Jersey car crash? How the 50% rule, PIP, and policy minimums shape recovery.

Edward P. CapozziBrach Eichler
Duration: 9:38544 views

Key Takeaways

  • In New Jersey, an injured driver can recover only if their share of fault is not greater than the defendant's, and the award is reduced by their percentage of fault.
  • Under New Jersey's no-fault system, your own auto policy's PIP coverage pays your medical bills regardless of who caused the crash.
  • New Jersey's minimum bodily injury liability limits are now $35,000 per person and $70,000 per accident, so buying adequate underinsured motorist coverage remains important.

If you are hurt in a car accident in New Jersey but were partly to blame, can you still recover? And who actually pays when a jury splits the fault?

In this TalksOnLaw Brief, Joel Cohen talks with Edward P. Capozzi, a certified civil trial attorney and member of Brach Eichler LLC in Roseland, New Jersey, about New Jersey's modified comparative negligence rule, how it compares with other states, and how the state's no-fault insurance system fits in.

Three Approaches to Shared Fault

Capozzi describes three systems. Under pure comparative negligence, used in states such as New York and California, a plaintiff can recover even if found 99 percent at fault, collecting 1 percent of the award. At the other extreme, pure contributory negligence, which survives in only a few places such as Virginia, bars any recovery if the plaintiff is even 1 percent at fault.

New Jersey sits in between with modified comparative negligence. A plaintiff can recover as long as he or she is not more negligent than the party being sued, and the award is reduced by the plaintiff's share. Found 40 percent at fault on a $100 verdict, you collect $60. At 50-50 you collect $50, but at 51 percent you collect nothing.

Who Pays and How Juries See It

In practice, Capozzi explains, the defendant's insurer pays, but jurors are not told about insurance. He believes juries sometimes hold back out of sympathy for a defendant who seems unable to pay. In some cases the insurer defending the claim may even be the plaintiff's own carrier. For a close case, he offers the left-turn collision: the turning driver should have yielded, but juries have assigned 40 percent or more of the fault to an oncoming driver who could have slowed down, especially one who was speeding.

No-Fault Insurance and Policy Limits

New Jersey is a no-fault state, Capozzi explains, meaning auto policies include personal injury protection (PIP). Whoever caused the crash, your own auto carrier pays your medical bills, and once PIP is exhausted, treatment can shift to private health insurance. He also notes how small many policies are, including a basic policy option, and urges drivers to buy enough underinsured motorist coverage to protect themselves against at-fault drivers carrying minimal limits.

What to Know Now

New Jersey's comparative negligence statute, N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.1, still bars recovery only when the plaintiff's negligence is greater than that of the defendants, and still reduces damages by the plaintiff's percentage of fault. The insurance picture has changed since this video. A 2022 law raised the state's minimum bodily injury liability limits in two steps, to $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident in 2023, and to $35,000 and $70,000 as of January 1, 2026, with property damage coverage at $25,000. New York's minimums remain $25,000 and $50,000. Capozzi's core advice holds: many drivers still carry only the minimum, so reviewing your own PIP and underinsured motorist coverage is a sensible step.

Additional Resources

Statutes

  • N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.1 (current): New Jersey's modified comparative negligence statute barring recovery when the plaintiff is more at fault.
  • P.L. 2022, c. 87 (2022): Raised New Jersey's minimum auto liability limits in phases, reaching $35,000/$70,000 on January 1, 2026.
  • N.J.S.A. 39:6A-4 (current): The New Jersey provision requiring personal injury protection (PIP) coverage in standard auto policies.