Series: Family Law →

What Are the Risks of Sperm Donation?

What known and anonymous sperm donors should know about parentage, child support, and donor agreements

Prof. Glenn CohenDeputy Dean, Harvard Law School
Duration: 1:3911,992 views

Key Takeaways

  • Whether a sperm donor can be treated as a legal parent depends on state law, and donating through a licensed physician often provides more protection than at-home insemination.
  • Known donors can reduce their risk with a lawyer-reviewed agreement and limited parent-like contact with the child, but some courts have still found donors to be legal parents.
  • Donor anonymity is no longer assured in practice, since consumer DNA testing can identify donors and Colorado now requires donors to agree that their identity may be released when offspring turn 18.

Thinking about becoming a sperm donor, perhaps for a friend? Before you do, it is worth asking a question many donors never consider: could the law someday treat you as the child's parent, with the child support obligations that come with it?

In this TalksOnLaw Brief, I. Glenn Cohen, Deputy Dean and the James A. Attwood and Leslie Williams Professor of Law at Harvard Law School and Faculty Director of the Petrie-Flom Center for Health Law Policy, Biotechnology, and Bioethics, explains the legal risks of sperm donation and the steps donors can take to protect themselves. Cohen is one of the leading scholars of law and bioethics, and in under two minutes he lays out the choices that matter most.

Known or Anonymous?

Cohen explains that a donor's first choice is whether to donate anonymously or as a known donor. In the United States, he says, anonymous donors are the most protected from someone later seeking to name them as a father and pursue child support. Known donation, such as giving sperm to a friend who has asked, carries more legal risk, and the rules vary from state to state.

Protecting Yourself as a Known Donor

For known donors, Cohen offers four practical steps. If possible, donate to a married individual rather than an unmarried one; many state laws treat a consenting spouse as the child's other legal parent. Involve a physician, because insemination performed by a licensed physician is often given more legal protection than at-home insemination. Limit contact with the child after birth, since courts in some cases have treated donors who attended birthday parties and formed relationships with the child as de facto parents. And have a lawyer review a written agreement declaring that you are not the parent, while recognizing that in some states, under certain circumstances, courts have still held donors to be legal fathers despite such agreements.

The physician point can be decisive. In a widely reported Kansas case, a known donor who answered an online ad and signed a waiver was initially ruled in 2014 to be the child's legal father, and so liable for child support, because no licensed physician was involved in the insemination, before a 2016 ruling found he was not the child's legal father.

What to Know Now

Cohen's core advice remains sound, and parentage law continues to evolve. The Uniform Parentage Act of 2017, adopted in a number of states, provides that a donor is not a parent of a child conceived through assisted reproduction, without requiring that a physician be involved, and it applies equally to married and unmarried intended parents of any gender. Because adoption is uneven, donors still need to check the law of their own state.

Anonymity has also changed. Consumer genetic testing now allows many donor-conceived people to identify biological relatives, including donors, regardless of any promise of confidentiality. And Colorado's 2022 donor-conceived persons law, which took effect for donations in 2025, requires clinics and banks to use only donors who agree that their identity may be disclosed to offspring once they turn 18. Supporters say the law respects donor-conceived people's interest in knowing their origins, while some in the fertility field worry it could reduce the number of willing donors. In most states, identity release does not itself make a donor a legal parent, but prospective donors should expect less anonymity than in the past.

Additional Resources

Statutes and Model Laws

Cases

  • Kansas Department for Children and Families v. William Marotta (2014): The Kansas known-donor dispute that turned on the absence of a licensed physician, illustrating Cohen's advice to involve one.