Key Takeaways
- Public health measures such as quarantines and stay-at-home orders belong mainly to the states under their traditional police powers.
- Congress's Commerce Clause power might reach some pandemic restrictions, but no existing federal statute clearly lets the President cancel a governor's shutdown order.
- Under the Steel Seizure case, a President acting without support from Congress has little room to override state orders, and later Supreme Court rulings have also limited federal agencies' emergency powers.
When a pandemic hits and governors order businesses closed and residents to stay home, can the President simply override them? Could Congress?
In this TalksOnLaw Brief, Glenn Cohen, Deputy Dean and the James A. Attwood and Leslie Williams Professor of Law at Harvard Law School and faculty director of its Petrie-Flom Center for Health Law Policy, Biotechnology, and Bioethics, explains the constitutional balance between federal and state power in a public health emergency. His short answer to whether Washington can undo a governor's shelter-in-place order: probably not.
Public Health Is Mostly a State Power
Professor Cohen explains that, historically, the states have held most of the police powers, including most of the authority over public health law. Quarantines, stay-at-home orders, and business closures are exercises of that state power.
What Congress Could and Could Not Do
Congress has power under the Commerce Clause to regulate interstate commerce, but in his view these orders are mostly intrastate rather than interstate, because they concern the activity, or the inactivity, of people within a single state. Congress might try to pass a statute claiming an effect on interstate commerce, but it had not done so, and he knows of no existing statute that gives the federal government that authority.
He also addresses the dormant Commerce Clause, a doctrine that bars one state from discriminating against other states. Could shutting down businesses violate it? Probably not, he says. Courts typically ask whether there is an undue burden on out-of-state commerce, and governors acting from strong, bona fide public health motivations are unlikely to be found in violation.
The President's Article II Power
What about the President acting alone? Professor Cohen acknowledges that the President has robust powers under Article II, but he doubts they include inherent authority to reverse a governor without Congress. He points to Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer, the Steel Seizure case, in which the Supreme Court held that President Truman exceeded his power by seizing the nation's steel mills during the Korean War. Overriding a governor, he argues, would be an even greater claim of power. He adds a note of caution: the composition of courts changes, and judges are pragmatists who respond to the facts on the ground, as the saying that the Constitution is not a suicide pact suggests.
What to Know Now
The question Professor Cohen addresses was never squarely tested in court, because no President tried to override governors' orders through litigation. Later pandemic cases, however, explored the limits of emergency power in related ways. The Supreme Court ended the CDC's nationwide eviction moratorium in Alabama Association of Realtors v. HHS (2021) and blocked OSHA's vaccine-or-test rule for large employers in NFIB v. OSHA (2022), in both cases finding that the agency had gone beyond the authority Congress granted. In Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn v. Cuomo (2020), the Court held that state limits on worship must satisfy the First Amendment even in a pandemic, a reminder that state power is broad but not unlimited. The Court also took a narrow view of the dormant Commerce Clause in National Pork Producers Council v. Ross (2023), consistent with his skepticism about such claims, and the anti-commandeering doctrine of Murphy v. NCAA (2018) limits Washington's ability to dictate what state law must say. The national COVID-19 emergency formally ended in 2023, but the framework he describes, with broad state police power, limited federal override, and presidential power measured against Youngstown, remains the starting point for future public health emergencies.


