Series: Health →

Federal and State COVID-19 Vaccination Mandates

Can governments and employers require a vaccine authorized only for emergency use? The 2021 debate.

Prof. Dorit ReissProfessor, UC Law San Francisco
Duration: 8:462,622 views

Key Takeaways

  • The Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel concluded in 2021 that the emergency use authorization law does not bar public or private entities from requiring a vaccine.
  • In 2022, the Supreme Court blocked OSHA's vaccine-or-test rule for large employers but allowed the federal health care worker vaccination requirement to take effect.
  • The federal COVID-19 vaccine requirements have since been rescinded, but states and employers retain broad legal authority to require vaccines, subject to medical and religious accommodation duties.

Can a government or an employer require a vaccine that the FDA has authorized only for emergency use? In the summer of 2021, that was one of the most pressing open questions in public health law.

In this TalksOnLaw Brief, Dorit Reiss, Professor of Law and the James Edgar Hervey '50 Chair of Litigation at UC Law San Francisco and a leading scholar of vaccine law, explains the first wave of federal and state COVID-19 vaccine requirements and the legal reasoning behind them.

Mandates Under an Emergency Use Authorization

Professor Reiss explains that the emergency use authorization statute requires the Secretary of Health and Human Services to inform recipients that they may accept or refuse the product, which some read as forbidding mandates. In her view, the law says nothing about consequences for refusing and speaks only to the Secretary, so reading in a ban on employer, university, and state mandates reads a lot into silence. The Office of Legal Counsel agreed in a July 2021 opinion. She notes that the opinion is not binding in court and will receive little formal deference, but it binds federal agencies in practice and is well reasoned, while candidly acknowledging that her own views may shape that assessment.

The VA and California Requirements

The Department of Veterans Affairs then required vaccination for its health care workforce, with accommodations for disability and sincerely held religious objections. California announced a softer approach for state workers and health care workers: unvaccinated employees would not be fired but would face regular testing and masking. Professor Reiss explains that a state may set conditions for its own employees, and that a requirement for private health care workers would draw on the state's police power to protect public health. She places these measures on a spectrum of coerciveness, with test-or-vaccinate rules well below vaccinate-or-be-fired, and far below criminal penalties or forced vaccination, which no one proposes.

What to Know Now

The EUA question became largely academic when the FDA fully approved the Pfizer vaccine in August 2021 and the Moderna vaccine in January 2022, though the OLC analysis remains relevant to future emergencies. Broader federal requirements followed and reached the Supreme Court. In NFIB v. OSHA (2022), the Court stayed OSHA's vaccine-or-test rule for large employers, finding OSHA likely lacked authority to impose such a broad public health measure; in Biden v. Missouri, decided the same day, it allowed the requirement for health care workers at Medicare and Medicaid facilities. In 2023 the federal employee and contractor requirements were revoked, the health care rule was withdrawn, and the public health emergency ended. Religious accommodation claims also gained strength after Groff v. DeJoy (2023). States now diverge, with some restricting mandates and others preserving them, while the traditional police power framework of Jacobson v. Massachusetts continues to anchor the debate, even as some justices have urged reading it more narrowly.

Additional Resources

Opinions and Cases

Statutes and Orders