Series: Health →

Can Hospital Workers Be Fired for Refusing to Vaccinate?

Employer vaccine requirements for health workers and the ADA, Title VII, and union limits that apply

Prof. Dorit ReissProfessor, UC Law San Francisco
Duration: 4:055,713 views

Key Takeaways

  • Private employers, including hospitals, can generally require vaccination as a workplace health and safety rule, unless state law provides otherwise.
  • Workers with disabilities or sincere religious objections may be entitled to reasonable accommodation, and since Groff v. DeJoy (2023) an employer denying a religious accommodation must show substantial increased costs, not merely more than minimal ones.
  • Several states, including Texas, Florida, Montana, and Idaho, now restrict employer COVID-19 vaccine requirements, so the answer depends heavily on where the hospital is located.

When a hospital requires its staff to be vaccinated, can it fire the nurse or doctor who refuses? And what protections do workers with medical conditions or religious objections have?

In this TalksOnLaw Brief, Joel Cohen talks with Professor Dorit Reiss, Professor of Law and the James Edgar Hervey ’50 Chair of Litigation at UC Law San Francisco (formerly UC Hastings), about employer vaccine requirements for health care workers, the legal limits on them, and the ethical considerations behind them.

An Employer's Right, With Four Caveats

Reiss begins with ethics: those who work with vulnerable patients likely have an ethical obligation to protect them and their coworkers, including by getting vaccinated. Legally, she explains, employers can require health workers to be vaccinated, as many already do for influenza, and can fire employees who refuse to comply with a health and safety rule. She then identifies four caveats.

First, the COVID-19 vaccines were then available under emergency use authorization rather than full licensure, and Reiss saw real legal uncertainty about whether an EUA product could be mandated, despite EEOC guidance suggesting it could. Second, in a unionized workforce, the collective bargaining agreement may require the employer to negotiate with the union first, as Cohen notes could arise for airline pilots and flight attendants.

Disability and Religious Accommodation

Third, under the Americans with Disabilities Act, an employee with a disability, including a medical contraindication to the vaccine, is entitled to reasonable accommodation unless it would impose an undue hardship. Accommodation does not mean treating that employee like everyone else; it can mean wearing protective equipment, working apart from others, or working remotely. Fourth, Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 requires employers to accommodate sincere religious objections unless doing so imposes an undue hardship, which Reiss describes as anything more than minimal cost.

Reiss also questioned whether mandates made sense during the early rollout, when doses were scarce and could go to those who wanted them, with an exception for settings such as long-term care facilities serving very vulnerable residents.

What to Know Now

The basic answer holds: in most states, private health care employers may require vaccination, subject to accommodation. The Supreme Court in Biden v. Missouri (2022) allowed a federal rule requiring vaccination of staff at facilities participating in Medicare and Medicaid, while NFIB v. OSHA blocked a broader vaccine-or-test rule for large employers. After the public health emergency ended, CMS withdrew its staff vaccination requirement in 2023, leaving the decision to employers and state law.

The EUA question Reiss flagged was resolved largely in employers' favor. Courts dismissed challenges by Houston Methodist employees fired for refusing vaccination, with the Fifth Circuit affirming in 2022 and again in 2025. The FDA granted full approval to the first COVID-19 vaccine in August 2021, and in August 2025 replaced the remaining emergency authorizations with approvals for narrower populations.

The religious accommodation standard has changed. In Groff v. DeJoy (2023), the Supreme Court held that an employer must show that an accommodation would result in substantial increased costs in relation to its business, rejecting the more-than-minimal-cost reading of earlier precedent. State law has shifted too: Texas, Florida, Montana, and Idaho now restrict employer COVID-19 vaccine requirements to varying degrees. Supporters of these laws stress individual medical choice, while many health systems and public health experts stress patient safety, so employers should check both federal accommodation law and current state law.

Additional Resources

Supreme Court Decisions

Lower Court Decisions and Guidance