Series: Elections and the Presidency →

What is voter intimidation?

Threats at the polls, armed officials, and lies about when to vote: what counts as voter intimidation.

Suraj PatelAttorney
Duration: 3:14705 views

Key Takeaways

  • The law prohibits conduct that threatens, intimidates, or coerces a person to vote, not vote, or vote a particular way.
  • Voter intimidation is not limited to physical threats, and misleading voters about when, where, or how to vote can also break the law.
  • Intimidating voters can violate the Voting Rights Act and other federal laws, and most states impose their own fines and prison terms.

Suppose a committed partisan rounds up friends to call voters in a rival party's district and tell them to vote on November 28. Clever trick? No. The law treats it as voter intimidation. So what exactly counts, and how serious are the consequences?

In this TalksOnLaw Brief, Suraj Patel, an attorney who has taught ethics as an adjunct professor at NYU Stern School of Business and has worked on political campaigns, explains what voter intimidation is, the forms it takes, and some surprising examples from recent American elections.

Threats at the Polls

Patel explains that the law expressly prohibits conduct that threatens, intimidates, or coerces a person to vote, not to vote, or to vote in a certain way. The most obvious cases involve physical or verbal threats: showing up at a polling place, raising your voice, or threatening someone, including with a firearm. He points to episodes in American history when poll monitors or sheriffs sat in polling places with guns and urged people not to vote. That history, he notes, is why many states ban police uniforms, military garb, and other official-looking clothing at the polls.

Deception Counts Too

Voter intimidation is not limited to confrontations. Patel explains that deceptive practices, such as misleading voters about when, where, or how to vote, can also qualify. In Maryland's 2010 governor's race, the Republican candidate's campaign manager arranged a robocall to more than 100,000 voters before the polls closed, telling them the outcome had already been determined and thanking them. The effect, he says, was to tamp down turnout. In Franklin County, Ohio, in 2004, flyers claimed that because of heavy turnout, Republicans should vote on Tuesday and Democrats should wait until Wednesday, the day after the election.

Serious Penalties

Patel stresses that voter intimidation carries serious consequences. Beyond violating the Voting Rights Act and other federal laws, it is prohibited by most states' own statutes. He cites Pennsylvania, where the penalty can reach a $15,000 fine or seven years in prison. Those figures match Pennsylvania's election interference statute; the state's separate offense of intimidating voters carries up to a $5,000 fine and two years. These laws exist, Patel explains, because of a long and complicated history of intimidation by both public and private actors, and they protect the fairness and integrity of elections and each person's right to vote.

What to Know Now

The laws Patel describes remain in force, and courts and regulators have applied them to new tactics. The Maryland robocall led to criminal convictions for the campaign manager and the political consultant who produced the call. In 2023, a federal court in New York held that operatives who sent tens of thousands of robocalls falsely warning that voting by mail would expose people to police and debt collectors violated Section 11(b) of the Voting Rights Act. Artificial intelligence has added a new dimension: after AI-generated calls imitating President Biden's voice urged New Hampshire voters to skip the 2024 primary, the FCC confirmed that AI-generated voices fall under federal robocall restrictions and fined the consultant behind the calls $6 million, though a state jury later acquitted him of criminal charges.

Questions about poll watchers and firearms near polling places continue to prompt new state laws, while free speech principles, including the Supreme Court's 2023 decision in Counterman v. Colorado on what the government must prove to punish a threat, shape how far these laws can reach. The core message holds: efforts to frighten or mislead people out of voting carry real legal risk.

Additional Resources

Statutes

  • Voting Rights Act Section 11(b), 52 U.S.C. 10307 (1965): Prohibits intimidating, threatening, or coercing anyone for voting or attempting to vote.
  • 18 U.S.C. 594 (1948): The federal criminal ban on intimidating voters in federal elections.
  • Pennsylvania Election Code, 25 P.S. 3527 and 3547 (1937, as amended): The state crimes of election interference and voter intimidation behind the Pennsylvania penalties in the Brief.

Cases

  • National Coalition on Black Civic Participation v. Wohl (S.D.N.Y. 2023): Held that deceptive, threatening robocalls about mail voting violated the Voting Rights Act and the Ku Klux Klan Act.
  • Counterman v. Colorado (2023): Requires at least recklessness about a statement's threatening character before it can be punished as a true threat.
  • Burson v. Freeman (1992): Upheld a campaign-free zone around polling places to protect voters from intimidation and fraud.