Series: Elections and the Presidency →

Can a President "Obstruct Justice?"

What counts as obstruction, why a sitting president is not indicted, and how presidential immunity applies.

Prof. I. Bennett CapersProfessor, Fordham Law School
Duration: 2:22774 views

Key Takeaways

  • Obstruction of justice covers corrupt attempts to influence, impede, or obstruct an investigation or prosecution, and the key element is corrupt intent.
  • The Justice Department's long-standing position is that a sitting president cannot be indicted, leaving impeachment as the main check while he is in office.
  • Under Trump v. United States (2024), a former president can be prosecuted for unofficial acts but is immune for core constitutional acts and presumptively immune for other official acts.

Can a president be guilty of obstructing justice? And even if so, can a sitting president actually be prosecuted for it?

In this TalksOnLaw Brief, Bennett Capers, the Stanley D. and Nikki Waxberg Chair and Professor of Law at Fordham Law School and a former federal prosecutor in the Southern District of New York, explains what obstruction of justice means and why prosecuting a president for it is complicated.

What Counts as Obstruction

Professor Capers describes obstruction of justice as very open-ended: any attempt to influence, impede, or obstruct a criminal investigation or prosecution. The essential element, he explains, is that the conduct must be done corruptly, meaning the person acts with the intent to impede or obstruct an investigation. Federal law contains several obstruction statutes, including provisions in 18 U.S.C. § 1512 covering tampering with witnesses, evidence, and official proceedings.

Can a Sitting President Be Charged?

The harder question, Professor Capers says, is whether a sitting president can be prosecuted. In his account, the consensus among legal and constitutional scholars is that a president cannot be prosecuted criminally for any offense while in office, which is one reason the Constitution provides for impeachment. That view matches the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel, which concluded in 1973, and again in 2000, that indicting a sitting president would unconstitutionally undermine the executive branch. He points to Richard Nixon: obstruction of justice was the subject of the first article of impeachment approved by the House Judiciary Committee in 1974, and Nixon resigned before the proceedings went further. Once a president leaves office, Professor Capers notes, the general consensus is that a former president can be prosecuted.

What to Know Now

The Supreme Court addressed former presidents directly in Trump v. United States (2024). It held that a former president has absolute immunity from prosecution for actions within his core constitutional powers, at least presumptive immunity for other official acts, and no immunity for unofficial acts, and it limited the use of official acts as evidence. A former president can still be prosecuted, as Professor Capers explains, but obstruction charges based on official conduct, such as directing the Justice Department or removing officials, now face significant hurdles. Supporters of the ruling say it protects energetic executive decision-making; the three dissenting justices and other critics warn that it shields presidents from accountability for official misconduct. In the same term, Fischer v. United States read one widely used provision, 18 U.S.C. § 1512(c)(2), to require impairing records, documents, or other things used in an official proceeding. Federal prosecutors brought charges against former President Trump in 2023 that included obstruction counts; those cases ended after his 2024 election, when the special counsel sought their dismissal in light of the Justice Department's policy against prosecuting a sitting president. The Supreme Court has never decided whether a sitting president may be indicted, so impeachment remains the established check during a term.

Additional Resources

Cases

  • Trump v. United States (2024): Held that former presidents have absolute immunity for core constitutional acts, presumptive immunity for other official acts, and none for unofficial acts.
  • Fischer v. United States (2024): Narrowed 18 U.S.C. § 1512(c)(2) to conduct that impairs evidence used in an official proceeding.

Statutes and Opinions