Series: Elections and the Presidency →

The "crime" of the ballot selfie!?

Is it illegal to take a selfie with your ballot? Why some states ban ballot photos and how courts responded.

Suraj PatelAttorney
Duration: 1:48341 views

Key Takeaways

  • Some states make it illegal to photograph or share your marked ballot, mainly to prevent vote buying and voter coercion.
  • Courts have split on these bans: a federal appeals court struck down New Hampshire's law in 2016, while a federal court upheld New York's ban in 2017.
  • Ballot selfie rules differ from state to state and can change, so check your state election office's guidance before taking a photo of your ballot.

You have just voted, maybe for the first time, and you want to share the moment. So you snap a picture of your ballot and post it to Instagram, Snapchat, and Facebook. Have you committed a crime?

In this TalksOnLaw Brief, Suraj Patel, an attorney who teaches business ethics as an adjunct professor at NYU Stern School of Business and has worked on political campaigns, explains why some states ban the ballot selfie, and why civil liberties groups have challenged those bans in court.

Doesn't the First Amendment Protect My Selfie?

Patel starts with the obvious objection. Sharing a picture of your ballot, and telling the world how you voted, looks like core political speech. If the First Amendment protects anything, he asks, shouldn't it protect that?

The Vote-Buying Rationale

There is a legitimate reason for these laws, Patel explains. Imagine someone running a scheme to buy votes. The best way to verify that the people being paid actually voted as instructed would be a photograph of the marked ballot. States adopted bans on photographing ballots for this reason, to protect the secrecy of the ballot and the integrity of the voting process. A secret ballot works only if no one can prove to anyone else how they voted.

Bans Under Challenge

Patel notes that the ACLU and others have challenged ballot photo bans, arguing that voters' First Amendment rights should prevail. While those challenges proceed, he cautions, many bans remain in effect. His advice: before you snap that selfie, know that it may be illegal where you vote.

What to Know Now

The legal landscape has shifted since this Brief was made, though it still depends on where you vote. Shortly before it was published, the First Circuit held in Rideout v. Gardner that New Hampshire's ban swept too broadly to survive First Amendment review, noting the lack of evidence that ballot selfies were being used to buy votes. California changed its law to allow voters to share pictures of their own ballots. Michigan settled a challenge in 2019 and now lets voters photograph their own ballot inside the voting booth, while still restricting photography elsewhere in the polling place. On the other side, a federal court in New York upheld that state's ban in Silberberg v. Board of Elections (2017), finding the state's interest in preventing coercion and vote buying sufficient.

Election-law trackers counted roughly 15 states that still prohibit ballot selfies as of 2024, with others permitting them or imposing conditions, such as no photos of other voters or none inside the polling place. Supporters of bans stress ballot secrecy and the risk of coercion; opponents stress political expression and the rarity of documented vote buying. The practical takeaway Patel offers holds: check your state's rules before you post. Your state election office or secretary of state's website is the best place to start.

Additional Resources

Cases

  • Rideout v. Gardner (1st Cir. 2016): Struck down New Hampshire's ban on sharing photos of marked ballots as overly broad under the First Amendment.
  • Silberberg v. Board of Elections of the State of New York (S.D.N.Y. 2017): Upheld New York's ban on photography of marked ballots at polling places.
  • Crookston v. Johnson (6th Cir. 2016): Allowed Michigan's ban to remain in force for the 2016 election; the case later settled in 2019.
  • Burson v. Freeman (1992): Upheld a campaign-free zone near polling places, recognizing states' strong interest in protecting voters from intimidation and fraud.
  • Minnesota Voters Alliance v. Mansky (2018): Struck down a vague ban on political apparel at polling places, while affirming that states may regulate speech there.