The legal profession likes to think of itself as the place where workplace harassment gets litigated, not where it happens. The #MeToo movement made that harder to believe. Law is a small, fraternity-like profession where careers depend on a handful of partners and judges, where claims are hard to prove and routinely dismissed, and where the people with the least power have the most to lose by speaking up.

In this TalksOnLaw interview, recorded in 2019, Joel Cohen speaks with Paulette Brown, the first woman of color to serve as President of the American Bar Association and a longtime labor and employment litigator who served as Senior Partner and Chief Diversity and Inclusion Officer at Locke Lord, about what sexual harassment looks like inside law firms, why it so rarely surfaces, and what firms should be doing about it.

Why Now

Brown credits Tarana Burke with founding the movement and explains why it landed in law when it did: lawyers are far more mobile than they were a generation ago, so reporting no longer means ending a career at the only firm you will ever work for. She walks through the basics of the law as it then stood: harassment as a form of discrimination under Title VII and state law, the "severe or pervasive" standard, the reasonable-person test, hostile work environments, and why an employer is generally liable only when the harasser is a decision-maker or the conduct was reported through official channels. Telling a friend, she warns, is not a complaint, though telling a friend that you complained can later corroborate it.

The Quiet Forms of Harm

Not every problem is a crude remark. Brown describes the "Mike Pence effect," in which male partners decline to travel or dine with female associates, and explains why that caution becomes a pretext for steering the best work to men. She turns to judicial clerkships, where a judge's power over a young lawyer's future is nearly absolute and the credibility gap is at its widest, and recounts a lawyer who stayed silent because coming forward "would be my career." Lawyers, she notes, file pay-equity claims far more readily than harassment claims.

Policies, Relationships, and Reporting

Brown offers practical guidance for firms: written policies covering conduct, office relationships, social media, and firm social events; reporting channels through human resources or an ombudsperson; annual training that is more than a checked box; mandatory investigations once a complaint is made, with a chance for the accused to respond; and a rule that any partner who hears a complaint must report it, so confidentiality can never be promised. On office romance, she is practical rather than prohibitive: consensual relationships are not harassment, but they should be disclosed, a supervisor cannot fairly evaluate a subordinate they are dating, and "no means no." Asking a second time after a refusal, she says, is where harassment can begin. She closes with advice to associates: reporting is a personal decision, but the behavior will not stop until someone does.

What to Know Now

The legal standards Brown describes have shifted, especially in New York. Since October 2019, harassment under the New York State Human Rights Law no longer needs to be "severe or pervasive"; conduct is actionable unless it amounts to no more than petty slights or trivial inconveniences, and an employee's failure to use the employer's complaint procedure is no longer a defense. New York also requires annual anti-harassment training. At the federal level, the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act (2022) lets employees take these claims to court despite an arbitration agreement, and the Speak Out Act (2022) makes pre-dispute nondisclosure clauses covering sexual harassment unenforceable. New York and California now allow confidentiality in a harassment settlement only at the complainant's preference. The EEOC's 2024 harassment guidance was partly vacated by a federal court in 2025 and rescinded by the Commission in January 2026, but the underlying Title VII obligations are unchanged.

The profession's own rules have moved too. ABA Model Rule 8.4(g), which makes harassment and discrimination in conduct related to the practice of law a disciplinary offense, has been adopted in some form by New York (2022), Pennsylvania, Vermont, Maine, New Mexico, and Illinois, while several states have declined it. A First Amendment challenge to Pennsylvania's version failed in the Third Circuit in 2023, and the Supreme Court declined review in 2024. The data remain sobering: the International Bar Association's 2019 global survey found one in three women lawyers had been sexually harassed at work, and the 2020 "Still Broken" study of U.S. legal workplaces found that 86 percent of incidents went unreported. New York now requires experienced attorneys to complete a diversity, inclusion, and elimination-of-bias CLE credit each cycle.

Brown now leads her own consultancy, MindSetPower LLC. Locke Lord merged into Troutman Pepper Locke in 2025.