Why Law Firms Implode

An interview with Prof. John Morley

Law firm failures do not merely signify bankruptcy - they are spectacles of grand implosions. American law firms suffer from unique structural risks that can drive these formidable institutions to not just falter, but rapidly collapse even where their balance sheets and profitability would suggest more durability. This phenomenon, far from random, stems from the fragile ownership structure unique to the legal industry. In an interview with Yale Law Professor John Morley, we take a deep dive into the inherent risks and dramatic consequences of law firm failures, and why this topic should command our attention. 

Law firms are peculiar entities in the realm of business: partner-owned and restricted from nonlawyer investment or ownership, as mandated by the ABA's Model Rules of Professional Conduct. When a law firm faces a financial crisis, this fragile structure can trigger a devastating cascade. Senior partners, or 'rainmakers', may depart, taking clients, associates, and their capital contributions with them, leading to a 'partner run'. This domino effect of departures, combined with the onerous burden of unfinished business liability and potential clawback provisions, makes the failing law firm's situation perilous. Professor Morley's interview provides enlightening perspectives and unpacks the intricate complexities that have contributed to some of the most notorious law firm collapses, such as Dewey & LeBoeuf and Brobeck, Phleger & Harrison. 

Drawing on detailed analysis, Professor Morley not only discusses potential management strategies to reduce costs, build loyalty, and disincentivize partner runs, but also policy solutions like modifying restrictions on partner withdrawals or even rethinking the prohibition on non-lawyer ownership.


  • Attorney CLE accreditation 

Additional Resources

Why Law Firms Collapse – a Yale Law and Economics Research Paper by John Morley (Revised 2020)

Relevant Ethics Rules

  • Rule 5.4(d): Professional Independence of a Lawyer

    (d) A lawyer shall not practice with or in the form of a professional corporation or association authorized to practice law for a profit, if

(1) a nonlawyer owns any interest therein, except that a fiduciary representative of the estate of a lawyer may hold the stock or interest of the lawyer for a reasonable time during administration;

(2) a nonlawyer is a corporate director or officer thereof or occupies the position of similar responsibility in any form of association other than a corporation ; or

(3) a nonlawyer has the right to direct or control the professional judgment of a lawyer.

  • Rule 5.6: Restrictions on Rights to Practice Share

Law Firms And Associations A lawyer shall not participate in offering or making: (a) a partnership, shareholders, operating, employment, or other similar type of agreement that restricts the right of a lawyer to practice after termination of the relationship, except an agreement concerning benefits upon retirement; or (b) an agreement in which a restriction on the lawyer's right to practice is part of the settlement of a client controversy.

Judge Raja Rajeswari discusses A Different Path to the Bench
A Different Path to the Bench
Prof. Nathalie Martin discusses A Mindful Practice (Part 2)
A Mindful Practice (Part 2)
M. Dru Levasseur discusses A Transition in the Legal Profession
A Transition in the Legal Profession
M. Dru Levasseur discusses A Transition in the Legal Profession (Part 2)
A Transition in the Legal Profession (Part 2)
Judge Jenny Rivera discusses Diversity in Justice
Diversity in Justice
Prof. Peter Joy discusses Ethics and Batson
Ethics and Batson
Prof. Peter Huang discusses Fighting the Zombie-Lawyer Apocalypse
Fighting the Zombie-Lawyer Apocalypse
Nicole Hyland discusses From Facebook to Tinder:  The Ethics of Social Media
From Facebook to Tinder: The Ethics of Social Media
Prof. Peter Joy discusses Investigating the Client
Investigating the Client
Nicole Hyland discusses Lawyer Ads Gone Wrong
Lawyer Ads Gone Wrong
Sarah McShea discusses Lawyering Beyond State Lines
Lawyering Beyond State Lines
Eileen Travis and Meredith Heller discusses Lawyers and the Bottle (Part 2)
Lawyers and the Bottle (Part 2)
Professor Tanina Rostain discusses Lawyers + LLMs: AI Ethics
Lawyers + LLMs: AI Ethics
Paulette Brown discusses Lawyers with Bias
Lawyers with Bias
Prof. Lenni Benson discusses Lawyers without Papers - Immigration and Legal Ethics
Lawyers without Papers - Immigration and Legal Ethics
Prof. Lisa Pruitt discusses Legal Deserts (Part 2)
Legal Deserts (Part 2)
Prof. Anthony Sebok discusses Legal Innovation – Investing in Lawsuits
Legal Innovation – Investing in Lawsuits
Prof. Anthony Sebok discusses Legal Innovation – Investing in Lawsuits (Part 2)
Legal Innovation – Investing in Lawsuits (Part 2)
Profs Bruce Green & Rebecca Roiphe discusses Line Prosecutors v. Main Justice
Line Prosecutors v. Main Justice
Paulette Brown discusses #MeToo Challenges in the Legal Profession
#MeToo Challenges in the Legal Profession
Prof. Nathalie Martin discusses Mindfulness & Attorney Stress
Mindfulness & Attorney Stress
Prof. Peter Huang discusses Model Minority & Associates
Model Minority & Associates
john a. powell discusses Modern Discrimination, Race & Inequality
Modern Discrimination, Race & Inequality
Terri Adler discusses Negotiation Strategies for Powerful Women
Negotiation Strategies for Powerful Women
Terri Adler discusses Negotiation Strategies for Powerful Women (Part 2)
Negotiation Strategies for Powerful Women (Part 2)
Prof. Carrie Menkel-Meadow discusses Out of Bounds – Negotiations Ethics
Out of Bounds – Negotiations Ethics
Lisa Smith discusses Overachieving, Anxiety, & Addiction
Overachieving, Anxiety, & Addiction
Lisa Smith discusses Overachieving, Anxiety, & Addiction (Part 2)
Overachieving, Anxiety, & Addiction (Part 2)
Profs Bruce Green & Rebecca Roiphe discusses Prosecutorial Discretion – Police Killings and Sexual Abuse
Prosecutorial Discretion – Police Killings and Sexual Abuse
Profs Bruce Green & Rebecca Roiphe discusses Prosecutorial Discretion – Power & Responsibility
Prosecutorial Discretion – Power & Responsibility
Alicia Bannon discusses Recusal & the Bounds of Judicial Bias
Recusal & the Bounds of Judicial Bias
Jennifer Justice discusses RocJustice - Law of Hip-Hop
RocJustice - Law of Hip-Hop
Gary Reing discusses Substance Abuse and Recovery - A Lawyer's Story
Substance Abuse and Recovery - A Lawyer's Story
Brian Cuban discusses The Addicted Lawyer - A Profession in Crisis
The Addicted Lawyer - A Profession in Crisis
Brian Cuban discusses The Addicted Lawyer - A Profession in Crisis (Part 2)
The Addicted Lawyer - A Profession in Crisis (Part 2)
Brian Cuban discusses The Addicted Lawyer - A Profession in Crisis (Part 3)
The Addicted Lawyer - A Profession in Crisis (Part 3)
Robin Steinberg discusses The Case for Holistic Defense
The Case for Holistic Defense
Sarah McShea discusses The Dangers of a Lateral Move
The Dangers of a Lateral Move
Prof. Carrie Menkel-Meadow discusses The Ethical Limits of Negotiations
The Ethical Limits of Negotiations
Prof. Carrie Menkel-Meadow discusses The Ethical Limits of Negotiations (Part 2)
The Ethical Limits of Negotiations (Part 2)
Judge Raja Rajeswari discusses The Language Conundrum - Access to Justice
The Language Conundrum - Access to Justice
Prof. Leslie Levin discusses The Malpractice Insurance Dilemma
The Malpractice Insurance Dilemma
Prof. Leslie Levin discusses The Malpractice Insurance Dilemma (Prior)
The Malpractice Insurance Dilemma (Prior)
Jon Krop discusses The Mindful Lawyer
The Mindful Lawyer
Jon Krop discusses The Mindful Lawyer (Part 2)
The Mindful Lawyer (Part 2)
Profs Bruce Green & Rebecca Roiphe discusses The Power of the Prosecutor (Part 2)
The Power of the Prosecutor (Part 2)
Seymour James discusses The Right to an Attorney - Currently Under Threat
The Right to an Attorney - Currently Under Threat
Profs Bruce Green & Rebecca Roiphe discusses Trump Trials – A Survey in Legal Ethics
Trump Trials – A Survey in Legal Ethics
Prof. William H. Simon discusses Using Lawyers to Launder Money
Using Lawyers to Launder Money
Hal R. Lieberman discusses When Lawyers Break the Law
When Lawyers Break the Law