A lawyer needs insurance to drive to the office, but in all but two states needs none to practice law once she gets there. When an uninsured lawyer blows a statute of limitations or misses a filing deadline, the client who was harmed usually has nowhere to turn: plaintiffs' malpractice lawyers will not take a case with no collectible judgment, and bar discipline punishes the lawyer without compensating anyone. In some states as many as 40 percent of solo practitioners go without coverage.
In this TalksOnLaw interview, recorded in 2021, Joel Cohen speaks with Leslie Levin, the Hugh Macgill Professor of Law at the University of Connecticut School of Law and one of the leading scholars of lawyer regulation, about why malpractice insurance remains optional, what mandates and disclosure rules have actually accomplished, and why she sees the question as one of access to justice.
What Goes Wrong, and Who Pays
Levin explains the stakes: between three and five percent of insured lawyers face a claim in any given year, and that undercounts actual errors. Coverage typically pays for missed deadlines, failures to communicate, conflicts of interest, and not knowing the law; it excludes theft and most intentional misconduct, which client security funds address. The uninsured are concentrated among solo and small-firm lawyers, often those serving individuals rather than corporations, which is exactly where clients can least absorb the loss.
Mandates, Disclosure, and Doing Nothing
Only Oregon, through its Professional Liability Fund, and Idaho, since 2018, require private-practice lawyers to carry coverage. After the ABA's 2004 Model Court Rule on Insurance Disclosure, roughly half the states adopted some version of disclosure, which Levin sorts into three kinds: direct disclosure to clients (South Dakota's letterhead rule is the strongest), posting on the regulator's website where few clients look, and collecting the information without publishing it. The other half, including Connecticut, "the insurance capital," did nothing. Even direct disclosure, she notes, arrives too late in the engagement and means little to clients who do not understand what "uninsured" implies.
The Case Against, and the Evidence
Levin takes up the arguments bar associations make against mandates: cost, the lack of evidence of a problem, reduced pro bono work, more claims, and the prospect of insurers deciding who may practice. She answers with data, including a New Mexico study finding that fewer than one in five uninsured lawyers did any pro bono work, and with experience: Idaho's rule caused little disruption beyond some lawyers near retirement surrendering their licenses, New Jersey's minimum premiums run around $4,300, and Oregon's fund has operated for decades with high satisfaction and higher claim reporting because reporting does not raise premiums. She also describes insurers as "regulators at the margins," whose application questions shape conflicts systems and engagement letters. Her forecast: as states license nonlawyer providers and require them to carry insurance, the lawyer exemption will become harder to defend.
What to Know Now
No state has adopted a mandate since this conversation; Oregon and Idaho remain the only two. Washington, which Levin describes as having come close, chose disclosure instead: since September 2021, a Washington lawyer without at least $100,000 per claim and $300,000 aggregate in coverage must give written notice and obtain the client's written informed consent at the outset of the engagement. Georgia's bar voted in October 2021 to keep both insurance and disclosure optional. California, whose 2019 working group found 39 percent of solo practitioners uninsured, kept its Rule 1.4.2 written-disclosure requirement rather than impose a mandate.
The most notable new approach is proactive regulation of uninsured lawyers. Illinois has required uninsured lawyers with private clients to complete a four-hour online practice self-assessment every two years since 2018, and Ohio adopted a similar rule effective January 1, 2025: private-practice lawyers without coverage must complete a free proactive management course to register, on pain of summary suspension. Connecticut now requires lawyers to report their coverage status on their annual registration, and a proposal to mandate coverage has been before the Rules Committee of the Superior Court since 2025. Levin's prediction about nonlawyer providers has come true in Oregon, where licensed paralegals, authorized to practice in limited areas since 2024, must carry Professional Liability Fund coverage on the same terms as lawyers.



