Police Commands & Police Coercion

An interview with Prof. Rachel Harmon

Police commands are the cornerstone of law enforcement, at once projecting the authority of the state and instantly creating legal obligations for which the failure to comply can result in arrest, detention, or even the use of deadly force. But what are the limits of police commands?  When are they lawful and what rights do we have to disobey them when they are unlawful? Professor Rachel Harmon, a leading scholar on police law explains how police commands are the building blocks of police authority and can serve as the foundation upon which a peaceful resolution to a crisis is built. On the other hand, bad commands can create confusion, escalate tensions, and result in unnecessary use of force.  Prof Harmon explains the legal limits of police commands and how regulating them can play a critical role in reducing police abuse and unnecessary force.


  • Attorney CLE accreditation 

Additional Resources

Law and Orders – Columbia Law Review article by Prof. Rachel Harmon

Policing the Police – an interview with Prof. Rachel Harmon on the laws restraining police action and governing police accountability.

The Law of the Police –  Casebook written by Prof. Rachel Harmon exploring the complex array of federal, state, and local legal rules that govern police encounters with the public. (Aspen Publishing, 2021)

Do you have to comply with police orders? – a 7min legal explainer brief with Prof. Harmon. 

Prof. Deborah Tuerkheimer discusses A Credibility Gap in Cases of Rape
A Credibility Gap in Cases of Rape
Prof. John J. Donohue III discusses Analyzing Death - Race and Bias in Capital Punishment
Analyzing Death - Race and Bias in Capital Punishment
Christine Mott discusses Animal Cruelty and Domestic Abuse
Animal Cruelty and Domestic Abuse
Prof. Darrell A. H. Miller discusses A Race to the 2nd Amendment
A Race to the 2nd Amendment
Prof. Douglas NeJaime discusses Assisted Reproduction and Parental Rights
Assisted Reproduction and Parental Rights
M. Dru Levasseur discusses A Transition in the Legal Profession
A Transition in the Legal Profession
M. Dru Levasseur discusses A Transition in the Legal Profession (Part 2)
A Transition in the Legal Profession (Part 2)
Benjamin Brafman discusses Celebrity Justice & High Profile Defense
Celebrity Justice & High Profile Defense
Prof. Lenni Benson discusses Children at the Border
Children at the Border
Alex Zerden discusses Combatting Crypto Money Laundering
Combatting Crypto Money Laundering
Prof. Rachel Barkow discusses Confronting Mass Incarceration
Confronting Mass Incarceration
Prof. Rachel Barkow discusses Confronting Mass Incarceration (Part 2)
Confronting Mass Incarceration (Part 2)
Prof. Dorit Reiss discusses COVID-19 Vaccine Mandates
COVID-19 Vaccine Mandates
Lee Rowland discusses Cyberbullying and the First Amendment
Cyberbullying and the First Amendment
Michelle A. Reed discusses Cyber Defense: Private Funds & Banks (Part 2)
Cyber Defense: Private Funds & Banks (Part 2)
Prof. Kimberly Ferzan discusses Deadly Force as Self Defense
Deadly Force as Self Defense
Alexia Korberg discusses Dobbs v. Jackson, a Battleground for Abortion Rights
Dobbs v. Jackson, a Battleground for Abortion Rights
Prof. Kate Shaw discusses Donald Trump and the Weight of Presidential Speech
Donald Trump and the Weight of Presidential Speech
Amy Barasch discusses Empowering Women — Combatting Economic Abuse in a Pandemic
Empowering Women — Combatting Economic Abuse in a Pandemic
Heather McDonald discusses Fashion Piracy & Anti-Counterfeiting
Fashion Piracy & Anti-Counterfeiting
Attorney General Sean Reyes discusses Fighting Sex Trafficking - A New Approach
Fighting Sex Trafficking - A New Approach
Attorney General Sean Reyes discusses Fighting Sex Trafficking - A New Approach (Part 2)
Fighting Sex Trafficking - A New Approach (Part 2)
Prof. Nadine Strossen discusses Free Speech in a Social Media World
Free Speech in a Social Media World
Prof. Nadine Strossen discusses Free Speech vs Hate Speech on Campus
Free Speech vs Hate Speech on Campus
Prof. Richard Briffault discusses From Super PACs to Dark Money
From Super PACs to Dark Money
Prof. Richard Briffault discusses From Super PACs to Dark Money (Part 2)
From Super PACs to Dark Money (Part 2)
Prof. Samuel Issacharoff discusses Gerrymandering: The Art of Redrawing Elections
Gerrymandering: The Art of Redrawing Elections
Prof. Sarah Barringer Gorden discusses God & Football after Bremerton
God & Football after Bremerton
Prof. Jeffrey Rosen discusses Government Surveillance: Privacy & Technology
Government Surveillance: Privacy & Technology
Prof. Joseph Blocher discusses Gun Rights under Rahimi & Cargill
Gun Rights under Rahimi & Cargill
Lee Rowland discusses Hate Speech in America
Hate Speech in America
Lee Rowland discusses Hate Speech in America (Part 2)
Hate Speech in America (Part 2)
Evon Idahosa discusses Human Trafficking Fueling Modern Day Slavery
Human Trafficking Fueling Modern Day Slavery
Susanna Saul and Diane Feniello discusses In Defense of Abused Women (Part 2)
In Defense of Abused Women (Part 2)
Prof. Susan N. Herman discusses Individual Liberty in Post-9/11 America
Individual Liberty in Post-9/11 America
Prof. Stephen Vladeck discusses Inside the Shadow Docket
Inside the Shadow Docket
Phillip Miller discusses Jailhouse Law—Lawyering as an Inmate
Jailhouse Law—Lawyering as an Inmate
Phillip Miller discusses Jailhouse Law—Lawyering from Inside Prison
Jailhouse Law—Lawyering from Inside Prison
Prof. Richard H. Fallon, Jr. discusses Justice Forever – Life Tenure
Justice Forever – Life Tenure
Prof. Richard H. Fallon, Jr. discusses Justice Forever – Life Tenure  (Part 2)
Justice Forever – Life Tenure (Part 2)
Columbia Law School Faculty discusses Law in the Time of COVID-19
Law in the Time of COVID-19
Judge Andrew Napolitano discusses Mass Quarantines in the COVID-19 Crisis
Mass Quarantines in the COVID-19 Crisis
Prof. John J. Donohue III discusses Mass Shootings and Gun Laws
Mass Shootings and Gun Laws
Prof. John J. Donohue III discusses Mass Shootings and Gun Laws (Part 2)
Mass Shootings and Gun Laws (Part 2)
Prof. Emily Murphy discusses Memory Evidence (Part 2)
Memory Evidence (Part 2)
Hina Shamsi discusses Military Drones and Targeted Killing
Military Drones and Targeted Killing
john a. powell discusses Modern Discrimination, Race & Inequality
Modern Discrimination, Race & Inequality
Prof. Daniel Capra discusses Police Power and Personal Rights
Police Power and Personal Rights
Prof. Daniel Capra discusses Police Power and Personal Rights (Part 2)
Police Power and Personal Rights (Part 2)
Prof. I. Bennett Capers discusses Police Technology - From Body Cameras to Facial Recognition
Police Technology - From Body Cameras to Facial Recognition
Prof. Rachel Harmon discusses Policing the Police (Part 2)
Policing the Police (Part 2)
M. Chris Fabricant discusses Poor People Science & Wrongful Convictions
Poor People Science & Wrongful Convictions
Prof. Joel Reidenberg discusses Privacy & Technology in Today's Schools
Privacy & Technology in Today's Schools
Prof. Jeffrey Rosen discusses Privacy vs. Government Tech
Privacy vs. Government Tech
Kay Levine discusses Prosecutorial Overreach and Reform
Prosecutorial Overreach and Reform
M. Chris Fabricant discusses Pseudoscience and Dubious Forensics
Pseudoscience and Dubious Forensics
M. Chris Fabricant discusses Pseudoscience and Dubious Forensics (Part 2)
Pseudoscience and Dubious Forensics (Part 2)
Prof. Fred Smith, Jr. discusses Qualified Immunity of the Police
Qualified Immunity of the Police
Race, Police, and Imperfect Justice Panel discusses Race, Police, and Imperfect Justice
Race, Police, and Imperfect Justice
Race, Police, and Imperfect Justice Panel discusses Race, Police, and Imperfect Justice (Part 2)
Race, Police, and Imperfect Justice (Part 2)
Alicia Bannon discusses Recusal & the Bounds of Judicial Bias
Recusal & the Bounds of Judicial Bias
Professor Jody Madeira discusses Red Flag Laws & Domestic Violence Orders
Red Flag Laws & Domestic Violence Orders
Prof. John J. Donohue III discusses Regulating Guns: Smart Laws & Dumb Laws
Regulating Guns: Smart Laws & Dumb Laws
Prof. John J. Donohue III discusses Regulating Guns: Smart Laws & Dumb Laws (Part 2)
Regulating Guns: Smart Laws & Dumb Laws (Part 2)
Judge Andrew Napolitano discusses Replacing Scalia - Filling a Vacancy on the Supreme Court
Replacing Scalia - Filling a Vacancy on the Supreme Court
Judge Andrew Napolitano discusses SCOTUS 2016 - A Year without a Justice
SCOTUS 2016 - A Year without a Justice
Prof. Kimberly Ferzan discusses Self Defense and the Use of Deadly Force (Part 2)
Self Defense and the Use of Deadly Force (Part 2)
Profs Adam Cox and Cristina Rodriguez discusses Shadow Immigration and the Power of the Presidency
Shadow Immigration and the Power of the Presidency
Profs Adam Cox and Cristina Rodriguez discusses Shadow Immigration and the Power of the Presidency (Part 2)
Shadow Immigration and the Power of the Presidency (Part 2)
Judge Andrew Napolitano discusses State-Sanctioned Targeted Killing
State-Sanctioned Targeted Killing
Daniel Levy discusses Stolen Art, Forgeries & Nazi Plunder
Stolen Art, Forgeries & Nazi Plunder
Robin Steinberg discusses The Case for Holistic Defense
The Case for Holistic Defense
Jeena Shah discusses The Case of Scott Lively: Gay Persecution in Uganda
The Case of Scott Lively: Gay Persecution in Uganda
Prof. Dorit Reiss discusses The COVID-19 Vaccine and the Role of the State
The COVID-19 Vaccine and the Role of the State
Prof. Deborah Denno discusses The Criminal's Brain - Neuroscience in the Courtroom
The Criminal's Brain - Neuroscience in the Courtroom
Prof. Eric Goldman discusses The Law of Deplatforming
The Law of Deplatforming
Joel Cohen discusses The Leaked Opinion, Dobbs v. Jackson
The Leaked Opinion, Dobbs v. Jackson
David Sheehan discusses The Madoff Fraud: Unwinding a Ponzi Empire
The Madoff Fraud: Unwinding a Ponzi Empire
David Sheehan discusses The Madoff Fraud: Unwinding a Ponzi Empire (Part 2)
The Madoff Fraud: Unwinding a Ponzi Empire (Part 2)
Profs Bruce Green & Rebecca Roiphe discusses The Power of the Prosecutor (Part 2)
The Power of the Prosecutor (Part 2)
Kenneth Feinberg discusses The Price of Death - Compensating Victims
The Price of Death - Compensating Victims
Robin Steinberg discusses The Problem with Bail
The Problem with Bail
Seymour James discusses The Right to an Attorney - Currently Under Threat
The Right to an Attorney - Currently Under Threat
Prof. Richard Pildes discusses The Shifting Power of Political Parties
The Shifting Power of Political Parties
Prof. Richard Pildes discusses The Shifting Power of Political Parties (Part 2)
The Shifting Power of Political Parties (Part 2)
Mara Keisling discusses Transgender Battles - Access and Equality
Transgender Battles - Access and Equality
Mara Keisling discusses Transgender Battles - Access and Equality (Part 2)
Transgender Battles - Access and Equality (Part 2)
Prof. Theodore M. Shaw discusses Understanding SFFA v. Harvard
Understanding SFFA v. Harvard
Prof. Dorit Reiss discusses Vaccine Mandates for Children
Vaccine Mandates for Children
Columbia Law School Faculty discusses Vulnerable Populations in a Pandemic
Vulnerable Populations in a Pandemic
Hal R. Lieberman discusses When Lawyers Break the Law
When Lawyers Break the Law
Prof. Marci Hamilton discusses When Religious Freedom Harms Children
When Religious Freedom Harms Children
Prof. Marci Hamilton discusses When Religious Freedom Harms Children (Part 2)
When Religious Freedom Harms Children (Part 2)
Prof. Lisa Heinzerling discusses WV v. EPA and the Major Questions Doctrine
WV v. EPA and the Major Questions Doctrine